Infrared Temperature Sensor Comparison Buyer’s Guide
An in-depth guide to and comparison of some of the best infrared thermometers on the market from the leading brands in temperature measurement – i.e. Optris CS Vision R1M and Fluke Raytek Endurance.
For companies that are searching for the best infrared thermometer for their industrial process monitoring, there is no shortage of options from leading manufacturers.
First things first, it’s important to note that infrared thermometers, infrared pyrometers, radiation thermometers, and temperature sensors are all names for the same thing: a non-contact temperature measurement device.
The market is filled with a huge range of industrial sensors that specialise in contactless infrared temperature measurement for monitoring and controlling the temperature of processes and machinery.
So how do you decide which thermal sensor is right for your specific requirements?
In this comprehensive guide, we explain the key features, benefits, and technical specifications of infrared sensors, and give our detailed review on some of the top industrial infrared pyrometers available, including:
- Optris CSvision R1M
- Fluke Raytek Endurance ER1
- Impac ISR 6-TV Advanced (Advanced Energy)
- Ametek LAND SPOT R100
- DIAS DSR 55NV
By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of how to pick the best infrared sensor for your industrial application, budget, and technical requirements.
Pushed for time?
Here are our recommendations for the top infrared thermometers:
- Price: Optris excels for value-conscious users.
- Ease of use: Fluke ER1 is ideal for beginners.
- Advanced features: Impac and DIAS cater to specialised applications.
- Balance of features and affordability: Optris CSvision R1M is a strong contender.
Scroll down to compare features, benefits, technical specifications and applications.
What Are Infrared Thermometers?
Infrared thermometers, also known as infrared pyrometers or non-contact thermometers, detect and analyse infrared radiation emitted by objects.
These non-contact devices allow users to measure temperature variations without directly touching the target object – particularly where contact measurements are impractical or unsafe.
Benefits of Infrared Thermometers and Pyrometers
Infrared temperature sensors have a wide range of industrial applications, from predictive maintenance and process monitoring to quality control and non-destructive testing.
Providing real-time temperature data, these powerful tools help with predictive maintenance, improve efficiency, reduce energy usage, improve cost-savings and enhance overall productivity.
By utilising industrial infrared sensors and radiometric cameras in your applications, it’s possible to learn more about your process in a shorter time than ever before, improve the quality of a manufactured product and reduce the cycle times of machines.
Take a look at our comprehensive guides:
- How do infrared thermometers work?
- How accurate are infrared sensors?
- How can you improve efficiency with infrared cameras?
How Do I Choose An IR Sensor?
When choosing a good infrared temperature sensor, ask yourself the following questions:
- What temperature range do I need?
To ensure the device is capable of measuring your target temperature range accurately.
- Do I need a lot of durability?
Choose a rugged, IP-rated housing for harsh environments.
- What level of usability am I looking for?
Consider user-friendly controls and features that streamline your workflow.
Key Considerations When Choosing a Non-Contact Thermometer
Once you know your requirements, consider the following factors to help decide which industrial temperature measurement solution is right for you.
Temperature Measurement Specifications
- Temperature Range and Accuracy: Ensure the device can measure your required range with sufficient precision.
- Spectral Range: Understand how target material emissivity and spectral range impact accuracy.
Durability and Usability
- Durability and Environmental Rating: Choose a rugged, IP-rated housing for harsh industrial environments.
- Ease of Use and Features: Look for user-friendly controls, analysis software, and features that improve workflow.
Additional Considerations and Features
- Connectivity and Integration: Ensure seamless data transfer and compatibility with existing systems.
- Price and Total Cost of Ownership: Balance upfront cost with long-term value and ownership expenses.
- Ambient Temperature and Environment: Consider environmental conditions and choose appropriate protective accessories.
Top Industrial Infrared Thermometers Compared
We will be comparing the key specifications and features of the following leading industrial infrared pyrometers:
- Optris CSvision R1M – Excellent value, offering advanced features at a low price point.
- Fluke Endurance ER1 – More user-friendly for beginners but lacks advanced features.
- Impac ISR 6-TV Advanced – Ideal for specialised applications with high accuracy; however, it’s pricier and requires manual focus.
- Ametek Land SPOT R100 – Offers comparable performance but lacks user-friendly features.
- DIAS DSR 55NV – Versatile with a motor-driven focus system, but more expensive than other models.
Optris CS Vision – R1M
High-performance Temperature Measurement at a Competitive Price
The Optris CSvision R1M offers advanced features at a significantly lower price point compared to competitor models.
Unique capabilities include integrated crosshair laser and video sighting, a two-step brightness reduction filter, and “Smart Ratio Mode” for challenging applications. Its ability to accept high attenuation levels at lower object temperatures is a key advantage.
Key Features:
- Two-step brightness reduction filter
- “Smart Ratio Mode” for challenging measurements
- Temperature range up to 3000°C in 1-colour and 2-colour modes
- Excellent thermal sensitivity
- CompactPlus Connect software for data logging and analysis
- IP65 rating, 2x 0/4-20mA outputs, programmable I/O
- USB, RS485, Modbus RTU interfaces
- Field upgradable software and firmware
- 2-year warranty
At Process Parameters, we supply Optris infrared thermometers which are renowned for their next-level thermography.
View our range of IR cameras or contact us for a free quote.
Send An EnquiryGeneral Purpose IR Thermometers
General Purpose IR Thermometers
General Purpose IR Thermometers
Fluke Raytek Endurance – ER1
User-Friendly Infrared Sensor for Beginners
The Endurance ER1 by Fluke is a straightforward infrared solution, suitable for industrial inspections. It offers a 4-year warranty, integrated web server, and multiple sighting options, but lacks advanced features like video sighting and “Smart Ratio Mode”.
Key Features:
- Rugged IP65 housing
- Laser, visual, and LED sighting options
- Integrated web server for remote access
- Attenuation acceptance only at higher temperatures
- Electrical isolation for power, output, and interfaces
- Temperature range up to 3200°C
- Accuracy of ±(0.5% of reading +2°C)
- Response time of 10 ms (95%)
- 4-year warranty
Impac ISR 6-TV Advanced (Advanced Energy)
Advanced Features for Specialised Applications
The Impac ISR 6-TV Advanced is a high-performance pyrometer designed for specialised industrial applications. It offers advanced features like flexible temperature range up to 2000°C and high accuracy of ±(0.3% of reading +2°C) at temperatures above 1500°C, but lacks user-friendly features.
Key Features
- Flexible temperature range up to 2000°C in 1-colour and 2-colour modes
- Accuracy of ±(0.3%) at temperatures above 1500°C
- Fast response time < 2 ms
- Analogue video output, 0/4-20mA, relay, and RS485 interfaces
- Manual focus system (210 mm to 5000 mm)
Ametek LAND SPOT R100
Reliable Temperature Monitoring for Industrial Processes
The SPOT R100 from Ametek LAND is a reliable thermometer designed for industrial temperature monitoring. It offers advanced sighting and integration capabilities but lacks some user-friendly features.
Key Features
- Green SPOT pattern LED for visual sighting
- Remote focus capability (300 mm to infinity)
- Dual 0/4-20mA outputs, digital inputs, and relay outputs for integration
- Temperature range up to 3000°C in 1-colour and 2-colour modes
- Accuracy of ±0.5% of reading or 5 K
- Response time of 1 ms (90%)
- IP65 rating
DIAS DSR 55NV
Versatile Infrared Thermometer for Industrial Applications
The DSR 55NV from DIAS is a versatile infrared temperature sensor suitable for a range of industrial applications. It offers a motor-driven focus system and OLED display, providing unique features but at a higher price point.
Key Features
- Motor-driven focus system for precise adjustment
- OLED display for direct temperature readouts
- 0/4-20mA output and Modbus RTU interface
- Temperature range up to 3000°C in 1-colour and 2-colour modes
- Accuracy of ±(0.5% of reading +1 K)
- Accepts up to 95% attenuation at lower temperatures
- Response time of 5 ms (95%)
- IP65 rating
Other Infrared Thermometer Brands to Consider
FLIR: Renowned for professional-grade infrared devices across various price points.
Utrisys: Offers a range of industrial infrared thermometers with specific functionalities for different applications.
Best Infrared Thermometer Comparison Chart
A comparison table of some of the best infrared pyrometers for industrial applications.
Feature | Optris CSvision R1M | Fluke Raytek Endurance E1R | Impac ISR 6-TV Advanced | Ametek LAND SPOT R100 | DIAS DSR 55NV |
Spectral Range | 0.8-1.1 μm | 0.75-1.1 μm / 0.95-1.1 μm | 0.9 μm / 1.05 μm | 1.0 μm / 1.2 μm | 0.7-1.1 μm |
Temperature Range (1-colour) | 550-1800 °C (R1ML) 900-3000 °C (R1MH) | 550-1800 °C (E1RL) 1000-3200 °C (E1RH) | 600-1400 °C (MB14) 700-1800 °C (MB18) 800-2500 °C (MB25) 1000-3000 °C (MB30) | 400-1800°C | n/a |
Temperature Range (2-colour) | 600-1800 °C (R1ML) 1000-3000 °C (R1MH) | 600-1800 °C (E1RL) 1000-3200 °C (E1RH) | 600-1400 °C (MB14) 700-1800 °C (MB18) 800-2500 °C (MB25) 1000-3000 °C (MB30) | 550-1800 °C 400-1800 °C in Multi mode (auto switch between. 1C/ 2C): <550 °C 1C-mode/ >550 °C 2C-mode | 500-1200°C 600-1400°C 700-1800°C 800-2500°C 900-3000°C |
Video Sighting | 1280×960 px/ 8° HFOV/ 30 Hz/ 2-step brightness reduction filter | 1280×720 px/ 3.7° HFOV | 768×520 px/ 7° x 5° FOV/ FBAS analog video out | 512×288 px/ 30 Hz | 628×528 px/ 8° x 6° FOV/ FBAS analog video out |
Sighting | Integrated crosshair laser and video sighting | Laser, visual or LED sighting options, video not combined | Laser or visual sighting, no video | Green SPOT pattern LED, no video | Laser or visual sighting, no video |
Optical Resolution | 100:1 to 150:1 | 100:1 to 150:1 | 100:1 to 350:1 (MB25/MB30) | 200:1 | 40:1 to 240:1 |
Response Time | 1 ms (90%) | 10 ms (95%) | <2 ms (exposure time / 90%) | 1 ms (90%) | 5 ms (95%) |
Accuracy | ±(0.5% of reading +2°C) | ±(0.5% of reading +2°C) | ±(0.3% of reading +2°C) / >1500°C: ±0.6% of reading | ±0.5% of reading or 5 K | ±(0.5% of reading +1 K) |
Interfaces | USB, RS485, Modbus RTU | RS485, EtherNet/IP, Profinet | RS485 | Ethernet, Modbus TCP | RS485, Modbus RTU |
Smart Ratio Mode | Offers “Smart Ratio Mode” for challenging applications | No such feature | No such feature | No such feature | No such feature |
Brightness Reduction Filter | Unique two-step brightness reduction filter | No such feature | No such feature | No such feature | No such feature |
Setup | Easy setup via mobile app, field upgradable software/firmware | Integrated web server, external video grabber needed | Software included, cable not included | SPOT viewer software optional, integrated web server | N/A |
Warranty | 2-year warranty | 4-year warranty | 3-year warranty | 3-year warranty | N/A |
Price (EUR) | 2,150 | 5,272 (+250 for video / +200 for CF optics) | 4,900 – 5,400 | ~4,800 | ~4,500 |
The Best Infrared Sensor For Industrial Use
There’s no single “best” infrared thermometer for industrial use. The ideal choice depends on your specific needs and priorities.
However, some devices offer excellent value and features that make them strong contenders across various applications.
The Optris CSvision R1M stands out in the market by offering advanced performance and capabilities at a significantly lower price point compared to competitor models like the Fluke Raytek Endurance ER1.
Benefits of The Optris CSvision R1M:
- Excellent value – It provides advanced features at a competitive price point.
- Advanced functionalities – It includes integrated video sighting, a two-step brightness reduction filter, and “Smart Ratio Mode” for handling challenging measurement scenarios.
- Superior sensitivity – It boasts exceptional thermal sensitivity (< 50 mK) to detect minute temperature variations.
- Wide temperature range – It measures temperatures up to 3000°C in both 1-colour and 2-colour modes.
- Data analysis software – Unlike some competitors, it comes with built-in CompactPlus Connect software for data logging and analysis.
Here’s a breakdown of how Optris CSvision R1M compares to other popular options.
Fluke Endurance ER1
More user-friendly for beginners, but it lacks advanced features like video sighting. Ideal for those prioritising ease of use over extensive capabilities.
Impac ISR 6-TV Advanced
Excellent for specialised applications with high-temperature accuracy, but it’s pricier and requires manual focus.
Ametek Land SPOT R100
Performance is comparable to Optris, but it lacks some user-friendly features.
DIAS DSR 55NV
Versatile with unique features like a motor-driven focus system, but it’s more expensive than the Optris CSvision R1M.
Finding the Best Choice for You
Process Parameters offers a wide range of infrared thermometers and ratio pyrometers. Our expertise can guide you towards the most suitable solution for your specific application, and we provide free quotes to help you make an informed decision.
Send An EnquiryOptris CSvision R1M vs. Fluke Raytek Endurance ER1: Industrial Infrared Thermometer Showdown
Choosing between the Optris CSvision R1M and Fluke Raytek Endurance ER1 can be tricky.
Both are excellent industrial infrared pyrometers, but they cater to slightly different needs.
Let’s break down their key features to help you decide which one is right for you.
Value
Optris CSvision R1M: Stands out for its significantly lower price point.
Fluke Raytek Endurance ER1: Carries a higher price tag.
Features
Optris CSvision R1M: Packed with advanced functionalities
- Integrated video sighting for precise targeting.
- Two-step brightness reduction filter for optimised performance in challenging lighting conditions.
- “Smart Ratio Mode” for handling intricate measurement scenarios.
- Superior thermal sensitivity (< 50 mK) to detect minute temperature variations.
- Wider temperature range (up to 3000°C) in both 1-colour and 2-colour modes.
- Includes data analysis software (CompactPlus Connect) for efficient data logging and analysis.
Fluke Raytek Endurance ER1: Offers a more basic feature set
- User-friendly interface for ease of use, ideal for beginners.
- Multiple sighting options (laser, visual, LED) for improved targeting flexibility.
- Integrated web server for remote access and configuration.
Other Considerations
- The Optris CSvision R1M may require a steeper learning curve due to its advanced features.
- The Fluke Raytek Endurance ER1 lacks some advanced functionalities that might be beneficial for complex applications.
- Durability: Both devices boast rugged IP65 housing for harsh environments.
Raytek Endurance vs. Optris CSvision: Which is better?
The “best” device depends on your specific needs. If you prioritise affordability, advanced features, and data analysis software, the Optris CSvision R1M is a compelling choice. If ease of use and a user-friendly interface are paramount, the Fluke Raytek Endurance ER1 might be a better fit.
Summary
While the Fluke Raytek Endurance ER1 and other competitor models may offer specialised features or integration options that cater to specific application needs, the Optris CSvision R1M provides an excellent balance of performance, user-friendly features, and value for a wide range of industrial temperature monitoring requirements.
Interested in purchasing an infrared thermometer for your business?
Process Parameters can be your partner in selecting your perfect infrared thermometer and pyromoters. Our expertise will guide you towards the most suitable solution for your specific application.
Explore the wide range of infrared sensors and cameras that we offer. From high-temperature pyrometers to thermal cameras for condition monitoring and early fire detection, we can help. Or if you’re looking for an infrared sensor for a specific use, contact our team today.
Contact us for a free quote and let our team assist you in finding the best non-contact temperature sensor for your needs.
Email us at sales@processparameters.co.uk, call 01628 778788, or complete our online enquiry form.
Send An EnquiryGeneral Purpose IR Thermometers
General Purpose IR Thermometers
General Purpose IR Thermometers
Related Guides:
- How to Improve Manufacturing with an Industrial Camera
- How Does an Infrared Thermometer Work?
- Guide to Infrared Thermometer Calibration
- How Accurate are Infrared Thermometers?
- Using a Thermal Camera to Detect Heat Loss
- Choosing an Infrared Pyrometer
- What is a Pyrometer?
- What is Thermal Scanning?
- What is a Machine Vision Camera?
- Can You Improve Your Thermal Efficiency With Imaging Cameras?
- Pyrometer or IR Camera?
- Infrared Thermometer: How to Use for Enhanced Accuracy in Industrial Settings